

In late elementary school and early high school I had some terribly mediocre social studies teachers. They weren't awful, but they clearly had minimal passion for the subject (why always gym teachers? I had some fairly good ones, but what is with that connection?) and the subject came across as a curriculum requirement rather than an engaging and alive topic. It's funny though because in all our idealistic talk about getting primary source documents integrated into high school history I know my gifted learning high school class thoroughly rejected such moves. My class developed an immediate dislike for Mr. M and his unconventional emphasis on diary entries and non-"Big Men" individuals. Mr. M had won an award for innovative teaching methods but my classmates and I found him completely unrelatable in the classroom. He clearly had a lot of theory under his belt but his weak classroom management skills was the blood in the water that we frenzied upon. We were definitely hot-headed brats but I think it is important to remember that many high school students are and that is a reality to deal with. I am glad that we have two teachers in our own class to keep the perspective of the realities of teaching. Mr. M's class "should have" been the class that set my historical passions on fire, but it certainly did not.
As I discussed in class, it was my (optional) grade 12 international history since WWI class that really got me excited. In that class I felt like I was finally learning the background to all those casual references that my family and the media made to topics such as the Israeli/Palestinian conflicts, the Great Depression and the Cold War. It was like I was being let in on this adult secret, that I was old enough to learn about the past, and I ate it up. For me it was practical in that it helped me to understand the references I was constantly inundated with.
University was where I had my completely mind blown by a few extraordinary professors. A course on modern China introduced me to the concept of completely different worldviews and conceptions of the past. It was also the first class where I was explicitly encouraged to go beyond traditional text sources for information. The idea I could examine propaganda and art and clothing and food to tell a history was incredible. My first Indigenous history course expanded on these themes while introducing a history that couldn't be dismissed as a foreign subject. Learning how little I knew about an incredibly important part of my own country's history was shocking and the way in which it forced me to challenge my own assumptions and ingrained dichotomies made my brain physically ache.
This post getting long but it is an interesting topic and one that I don't often think about. Looking back, I guess my interest in history came in a few stages moving from exotic appeal to practical knowledge to a way of thinking. At least according to my unreliable sources that is.
Thanks for stimulating the conversation Libschoollady! (*Apologies for my initial misidentification of this blog writer*)
Very interesting Adair,
ReplyDeleteIt seems like you have had a lot of life experiences that have contributed to your interest in history. When you did finally recognize history as a field you wanted to pursue, did you immediately have a career goal in mind?
Just curious!
-Craig
Good question Craig! No, I don't think I had an immediate career goal in mind. I just loved the way that history made/makes me think and decided I wanted to have more of that in my life. For me the subject doesn't just stick neatly under the heading of History either; a lot of the "history" I love might be considered literature, art or complete nonsense by others. I still don't know exactly where I want to take my love for history in terms of a career, but I'm not too worried about that - learning through experience right?
ReplyDeleteAdair
I loved your post Adair! When I was thinking back I kept regretting that I was not a faithful journal-keeper as a child, nor as an adult. It's something I've always wanted to do but never really accomplished... New Year's Resolution?
ReplyDeleteHaha, agreed!
ReplyDelete